Introduction:
In the ever-complex world of financial markets, understanding the flow of capital between assets is crucial for anticipating price movements. Capital doesn’t shift randomly; it follows discernible patterns influenced by economic data, geopolitical events, and inter-market relationships.
This article focuses on how volume movements in one market can influence price directions in another. We examine two key markets: the 10-Year T-Note Futures (ZN1!) and Light Crude Oil Futures (CL1!), along with other significant markets such as ES1! (E-mini S&P 500 Futures), GC1! (Gold Futures), 6E1! (Euro FX Futures), BTC1! (Bitcoin Futures), and ZC1! (Corn Futures).
Our goal is to equip traders and investors with insights and strategies that enhance their ability to anticipate price direction based on the dynamics of volume flow. By leveraging the Granger Causality test, we identify predictive relationships between these markets and apply a targeted trading methodology using the Commodity Channel Index (CCI) and Volume Weighted Average Price (VWAP).
Understanding Granger Causality
Granger Causality is a statistical method used to determine whether one time series can predict another. It doesn't establish direct cause-and-effect but identifies if past values of one variable contain information that can predict future values of another. This is particularly valuable in financial markets, where understanding how one market's movements can influence another is key to successful trading.
Pros of Granger Causality:
- Predictive Power: Systematically determines if one market’s past behavior can forecast another’s, aiding in anticipating potential movements.
- Quantitative Basis: Provides a statistical foundation for analyzing market relationships.
Cons of Granger Causality:
- Lag Dependency: Test results depend on the chosen lag length, which may not capture all relevant dynamics.
- Not True Causality: Only suggests predictive relationships, not definitive cause-and-effect.
Understanding Money Flow via Granger Causality
We applied the Granger Causality test to daily volume data from January 1, 2018, to the present, focusing on a 2-day lag to capture short-term predictive relationships. The heatmap below visualizes the results, showing which markets have predictive power over others.
Key Findings:
- ZN1! (10-Year T-Note Futures): Demonstrates significant predictive power over CL1! (Light Crude Oil Futures), suggesting that volume increases in ZN1! often precede volume changes in CL1!.
- CL1! (Light Crude Oil Futures): While CL1! also influences ZN1!, the predictive power is stronger from ZN1! to CL1!, highlighting the importance of monitoring ZN1! volume for early signals in CL1!.
Trading Methodology
With these insights, we developed a trading methodology using the CCI and VWAP indicators to anticipate price movements in CL1! based on volume patterns in ZN1!.
Volume Analysis with CCI:
- Excess Volume: When ZN1!’s CCI is above +100, it indicates excess volume. If CL1!’s CCI is below +100 simultaneously, it suggests that ZN1!’s volume has not yet impacted CL1!, signaling a potential volume influx into CL1!.
Price Prediction with VWAP:
- Higher VWAP Today: If today’s VWAP is above yesterday’s, and ZN1! shows excess volume, we expect CL1! to make a higher high.
- Lower VWAP Today: If today’s VWAP is below yesterday’s, and ZN1! shows excess volume, we expect CL1! to make a lower low.
Application Steps:
- Identify Excess Volume in ZN1!: Use CCI to check if ZN1! is above +100.
- Assess CL1! Volume: Confirm if CL1! is below +100 on the CCI.
- Use VWAP to Confirm Direction: Compare today’s VWAP to yesterday’s to determine the expected price direction in CL1!.
Case Studies: Practical Application
Here are three case studies demonstrating this methodology in action:
- May 23, 2024: ZN1! had a CCI of +265.11, CL1! had a CCI of +12.84, and VWAP was below the prior day’s. CL1! made a lower low.
- June 28, 2024: ZN1! had a CCI of +175.12, CL1! had a CCI of -90.23, and VWAP was above the prior day’s. CL1! made a higher high.
- July 11, 2024: ZN1! had a CCI of +133.39, CL1! had a CCI of +0.23, and VWAP was above the prior day’s. CL1! made a higher high.
Conclusion
Understanding the flow of capital between markets is essential for anticipating price movements. By combining the Granger Causality test with CCI and VWAP, traders can gain a structured approach to trading that leverages inter-market dynamics. The case studies highlight the practical application of this methodology, showing how volume conditions in ZN1! can predict price movements in CL1!.
Key Takeaways:
- Granger Causality: A valuable tool for uncovering predictive relationships between markets.
- CCI and VWAP: When used together, they provide a robust framework for predicting price movements based on volume data.
Limitations and Risk Management:
- While Granger Causality is powerful, its accuracy depends on the lag lengths and data stationarity. Traders must also account for broader market conditions, including economic events and geopolitical factors. Effective risk management is crucial to mitigate potential losses from unexpected market shifts.
This article underscores the importance of combining statistical insights with technical analysis to make informed trading decisions. For more advanced tools to support your trading, consider exploring AutoUFOs® and AutoClimate™, which offer powerful solutions for identifying high-probability trades.
Want to read an expanded article with multiple TradingView charts that illustrate the application ? Check it out here: tradingview.com/u/traddictiv
- Follow us and Boost the TradingView Published Idea if you like it 👌
Want to know more about AutoUFOs® and AutoClimate™ ? Check it out here: tradewithufos.com/apps
TRADDICTIV · Research Team
